Home  /  George III half-crown obverse working punch

George III half-crown obverse working punch

Overview

Museum number

H 584

Country

United Kingdom

Ruler

George III

Object name

obverse working punch

Denomination

half-crown

Date

1816-1820

Object history

In 1817 George III was 79. Confined to Windsor Castle, his health was poor, he was physically frail and, with a long white beard, his appearance was said to be unkempt. The portraits of him on the silver coins issued as part of the major recoinage of 1817, by contrast, depict him in the prime of life, his lips full, clean shaven and with short-cropped vigorously curling hair. For the shilling and sixpence the same portrait by Benedetto Pistrucci was used, not dissimilar in neoclassical style to the approach of Nathaniel Marchant ten or more years earlier, whereas for the half-crown Pistrucci developed the so-called ‘bull head’ portrait in which the bare-shouldered king has a passing resemblance to an Ancient Greek wrestler.

Both these portraits had been copied at the Royal Mint by Thomas Wyon from originals prepared by Pistrucci but it was the bulky proportions of the effigy on the half-crown that attracted concern. The Master of the Mint, William Wellesley Pole, had been critical of the way Wyon had copied the work and in November 1816 was asking for corrections to be made. But, with the deadline for the issue of the new coins fast approaching early in the new year, it was all too late and Pole expressed himself to be ‘in despair when I think of the number of bad half-crowns we shall issue!’. The press agreed. Once the coins hit the streets in February The Examiner commented that ‘surely the artist must have been a wag or a Jacobin! - perhaps both Jacobin and wag’.

At the same time as journalists heaped scorn on the coin, preparations for its replacement were well advanced. The plan was to cut away part of the neck and shoulders and Pistrucci would then retouch the portrait from this new starting point. Although the effect of the alterations was to create a portrait that seems markedly changed, and the overall effect is certainly a good deal less brutish, a common origin can nevertheless be seen from the features of the face. A tool for the obverse of the pared-down half-crown was available from February and there is a possibility that this tool survives in Royal Mint Museum.

The half-crown punch pictured here has been worked over fairly thoroughly by an engraver so it would be unwise to draw from it firm conclusions, but there are areas of the surface that hint at remnants of the neck and shoulders in exactly the positions where one would expect details to have been carved away from the original half-crown portrait. Once completed, Pole and others whose approval was required, liked the revised version and it was quickly put into action. Precisely when production of the maligned original half-crown gave way to the new type is not clearly documented but a possible answer lies in the break in production of all silver coins between 4 March and 21 April, and Royal approval of the new design being received five days after the end of this break.

The story of the tool noted above, though, might not end there. Having alighted upon a likeness of the king that found favour, it was suggested that it be copied for other denominations, such as the sovereign and half-sovereign, by making use, for the first time, of the copying lathe housed at Matthew Boulton’s mint near Birmingham. Letters from February 1817 note that a punch of the revised half-crown portrait was sent from the Royal Mint in London to Birmingham, with the request that it be reduced to the size of a sovereign. The lathe, which we would now refer to as a reducing machine, did its job well and tools for the sovereign, and other denominations, complete with evidence of turning marks from the lathe, were despatched back to London.

So the controversy encountered over the design of the bull head half-crown not only advanced the engraving skills of Benetto Pistrucci and meant a new portrait was shared between the half-crown, sovereign and half-sovereign, but also introduced the Mint to an alternative way of generating master tools. Without wishing to stretch the bounds of the narrative too far, it is likely that this surviving tool in the Museum’s collection has a connection to all these aspects of the recoinage of 1817.

Production

Engraved by

Pistrucci, Benedetto